ripple logo
Search_label Login_but
Lily_brislen_pic "It's the Economy AND the Culture, Stupid"
Share

Having just returned from a week long training NeighborWorks Institute in New Orleans, I could hardly wait to share my experiences, and the lessons I felt the Rural Northwest can take from The Big Easy.

The recovery of New Orleans since Hurricane Katrina hit in 2005 has been much more expeditious than many initially dared to hope. Current numbers state that population is now nearly 80% of pre Katrina numbers. I’m definitely no expert on this issue, but I don’t think I’m alone in asserting that a strong local culture played a significant role in speedy reconstruction. It stands to reason that the stronger one’s sense of ‘home' (a network of people, traditions, dialects, foods, and places that are integrated into your personal identity), the more compelled one will be to return and rebuild. As far as strong local ‘flavor,’ there are few places in the US that can compete with New Orleans.
 


One of my instructors at the institute said that she had struggled to find a convincing argument for art as economic development. I would argue that culture, of which art is a large component, is the strongest force driving economics. People don’t put their futures on the line to rebuild an economy; they risk it all to rebuild ‘home.’ Conversely, economic activity serves as a primary catalyst for cultural development. This is demonstrated in New Orleans through the central role that the arts and music scenes have played in inspiriting and driving the rebuilding of the city.

Two organizations that I had a chance to visit are playing a key role in that process of cultural economic development. What makes these organizations noteworthy is the fusion of cultural and business development. More than promoting art for art’s sake, these organizations take a comprehensive approach to nurturing and growing artists, which necessarily includes a strong business education component and qualifies these programs as ‘economic development.’
 


New Orleans Arts Councils, among many other activities, offers Arts Business Programs to promote business skills for artists, organizing a monthly Arts Market to give artists direct access to their customers, and www.NOLAfunguide.com which seeks to “rebuild the area’s cultural infrastructure” by providing a comprehensive centralized events calendar. They also assist in accessing Louisiana Volunteer Lawyers for the Arts, who provide free legal assistance to low to moderate income Louisiana artists, and addresses specific issues such as copyright law.
 


We also visited the Tipitina’s Foundation Incubator. The humble incubator space, filled with computers loaded with digital editing software for music, film, and other digital media, serves as a hub for artists looking to build up the business end of their operation. From their website:

Tipitina’s Music Office Co-Op is a five-city network of media business training centers, serving more than 1,800 Louisiana musicians, filmmakers and other digital media workers. The Co-Ops provide technology access, instruction, mentoring, networking, and practical business infrastructure for creative entrepreneurs.


I was incredibly impressed by this organization, not only because of the fantastic service they provide, but also the strategic approach they take to evaluating and documenting their impact. While the stories behind the work of this organization and the art that the members produce are quite compelling, it can be easy to write off cultural development efforts as ‘fluff,’ especially during an economic downturn.  However, when you’re hit with the stone cold data regarding the results of their efforts, it’s hard to ignore. To provide just two examples:

  • Average music/media earnings among Music Office Co-Op members jumped 36% (from $4,726 to $6,427) in 2008. Despite small downturns in 2005 and 2007, average member earnings have increased 52% since the Co-Op began in 2003.
  • Return on investment was better than ten-to-one; for every dollar spent operating the Co-Op, its members realized $10 in new income and investment.


The lessons I took home from New Orleans, and that I hope to share, are that successful business development and community revitalization efforts utilize both a ‘numbers based’ approach focused on dollars and jobs, and more visceral activities that tap into the heart of a community. For example, we know that successful downtown revitalization efforts tie in to community history and fun cultural events with strategic business support and financing. Cultural and economic activities do not need to be tackled separately, but can, instead, inform and support each other.

The most uplifting aspect of the lessons I came away with, is that this type of ‘cultural development’ is something we can all have a hand in. When I go to hear Hotqua (a local gypsy swing band) play at our local wine bar, I’m not only supporting the arts in my community, but directly contributing to our larger economic well being. While we as individuals may not be able to recruit a new industrial plant to our community, we can support those businesses, organizations, and activities that give our community its unique character.

The natives of New Orleans didn’t return to the city because it had a lot of the same things you can find anywhere else; they were drawn back by those aspects of place that were irreplaceable. The same goes for those of us out 'in the sticks.' Those who venture back to struggling rural communities often site cultural reasons for their return, and community lead marketing and recruitment efforts for frequently site the 'rural lifestyle' as a key reason for 'heading ot the hills.' Just because cultural aspects of develpment aren't easily quantifiable, doesn't mean they don't play a pivotal role in building resilient communities.

What aspects of your community informed your decision to call it ‘home’?

What about your community is irreplaceable?



See all posts by Lily Brislen.

7
COMMENTS
Lily says
03.24.10 // 03:59 PM
Thanks to Joanne for that fantastic example! I often wish we rural folks had more opportunities to share these great examples, and it's great to see that RIPPLE can be one of those venues! I've been reflecting on the question 'Why Rural?' a lot lately; meaning, what's the argument for the continued existence of rural communities? What's taking shape in my head is that the foundation for an argument for 'Rural' will have to start with culture. A community has to be able to articulate who they are as a people, what their relationship is with that particular natural environment and geography, and what history ties them to that place. Those elements, to me, are the core of what community is. Otherwise you're indistinguishable from a subdivision or a strip mall... am I right?
Heidi says
03.23.10 // 09:29 AM
Lily, What an amazing blog, thank you for bringing your learning back from the Big Easy and sharing and to Joanne and Beth for other resources.
Joanne Steele says
03.21.10 // 07:51 AM
Hey Lily, I was struck by your statement that revitalization needs to tap into the heart of the community. Exactly! I have been following a rural organization, the Kansas Sampler Foundation in Inman, Kansas that is working with rural communities all over Kansas helping them to inventory their cultural assets in 8 categories. These Rural Cultural Elements become the basis of their tourism, economic development, revitalization, and general elevation in community pride. It's involving hundreds of towns in a beautifully organized, multifaceted process that has been working since 1995. Marci Penner, the Ex. Director is a wizard who won't leave her state, so I'm taking the idea on the road, speaking about it in April at the first British Columbia Rural Tourism Conference. Take a look Kansassampler.org.
Beth says
03.11.10 // 09:01 AM
Sarah, I loved that line also. I thought that it really captures WHY people live in rural places. I am sure that a lot of us doing rural development work have heard the "why don't the move" question from urban folks when we talk about the lack of resources and unknown futures for rural places. Lily really boils it down to the truth about why rural people are working to better and preserve their communities. It's home damn it.
Sarah says
03.11.10 // 08:42 AM
"People don’t put their futures on the line to rebuild an economy; they risk it all to rebuild ‘home.’" Yes!
Lily says
03.10.10 // 08:25 AM
Wow Beth! Thank you! This looks like a really great resource! The list of partners is impressive, but it makes me wonder why there aren't any purely economic development focused organizations on board. This seems like a prime example of a need to 'open the silos' of our development efforts.
Beth says
03.10.10 // 07:54 AM
Hey Lily, here's a resource you might be interested in: http://staging.oregonartscommission.org/creative_oregon/creative-vitality-index/ It's the "Creative Vitality Index" for Oregon that quantifies the type of development you're talking about for each of Oregon's counties.

Join the conversation! First time contributing? View Comment Guidelines.



LIMIT 2,000 CHARACTERS